One of the antler tips was broken. We decided it was less trouble to glue it back on rather than send it back. If we had sent it back, we may have received one in worse condition.
It is a pretty set, but mostly for decoration. We really use our fireplace, so we were afraid to use it with our woodburning fireplace. We set it downstairs with our gas fireplace. Was disappointed that it was broke and that it wasn't sturdy enough, in our opinion.